Unpaid Invoices at Year-End: Which Accounts Need a Follow-Up, a Payment Plan, or Legal Action?

Written by: Max Bedell, Esq
For Ohio businesses and organizations, year-end is an opportunity to evaluate outstanding invoices, prioritize collection efforts, and establish better payment practices for the coming year.
As 2026 comes to a close, many businesses and organizations are reviewing outstanding invoices and determining which accounts are likely to be collected. Some debtors simply need a reminder. Others may need additional time to pay. Still others may require legal action.
As a decision-maker, how should you determine which unpaid accounts to pursue and what steps are worth taking to recover the money owed?
The answer depends on more than the age or amount of an invoice. You should consider the available documentation, the debtor's payment history, whether the balance is disputed, and the likely cost of collection.
Start With an Aging Report
An accounts receivable aging report is a useful starting point. It identifies outstanding invoices and organizes them according to how long payment has been overdue, commonly in 30-day increments.
However, an invoice that is 90 days overdue does not necessarily require more aggressive collection efforts than one that is 30 days overdue.
For each account, consider the amount owed, the debtor's payment history, prior collection efforts, and any explanation for nonpayment. A business owner may determine that a longstanding customer who ordinarily pays on time warrants a different approach than a customer who has repeatedly missed payment commitments.
You should also identify accounts approaching applicable legal deadlines. Under Ohio law, the statute of limitations for filing a lawsuit to collect an unpaid debt generally depends on the type of contract involved:
· Written contracts: Six years from the date the cause of action accrued, pursuant to Ohio Revised Code Section 2305.06.
· Oral or implied contracts: Four years from the date the cause of action accrued, pursuant to Ohio Revised Code Section 2305.07(A).
· Contracts for the sale of goods: Four years from the date the cause of action accrued, pursuant to Ohio Revised Code Section 1302.98. The parties may agree to shorten this period to no less than one year, but cannot extend it.
The applicable deadline generally begins when the contractual obligation is breached, which may be when payment becomes due and is not made. However, the precise deadline depends on the agreement, the nature of the claim, and any applicable exceptions. Businesses should review older accounts carefully because allowing the statute of limitations to expire may prevent them from pursuing an otherwise valid claim in court.
The goal is to identify which accounts deserve immediate attention rather than treating every overdue invoice the same way.
Gather the Documents Supporting Each Balance
Before escalating collection efforts, confirm that you can establish both the amount owed and the debtor's obligation to pay.
Relevant records may include signed contracts, purchase orders, estimates, invoices, payment terms, change orders, delivery confirmations, and correspondence concerning the transaction.
For service providers and contractors, documentation showing that the work was completed can be particularly important. This may include completion reports, photographs, customer approvals, inspection records, or communications acknowledging satisfactory performance.
Businesses should also reconcile the account to confirm that payments, credits, and adjustments have been properly recorded.
An invoice establishes what the business billed. It does not necessarily establish that the customer agreed to the charges or that the business fulfilled its obligations.
Organizing these records before making a formal demand can strengthen the collection effort and help identify weaknesses that should be addressed before litigation.
Separate Disputed Accounts From Unpaid Accounts
Not every unpaid invoice represents an unwillingness to pay.
A debtor may dispute the quality of work, the amount charged, an unauthorized change order, or whether particular goods or services were delivered.
These disputes should be evaluated before deciding how to proceed.
Review the debtor's objections alongside the contract and supporting documentation. Determine whether the objection concerns the entire balance or only a portion of it.
Where appropriate, resolving a legitimate billing issue or obtaining payment of the undisputed amount may be more productive than immediately pursuing the entire invoice.
You should also document any proposed compromise. An informal agreement to accept a reduced amount can create uncertainty if the parties do not specify whether the payment resolves the entire obligation.
Match the Collection Approach to the Account
Once the accounts have been reviewed, you can generally divide them into three categories.
Follow-up: Accounts involving relatively recent invoices, reliable customers, or administrative delays may be resolved through a direct reminder. Confirm the balance, provide supporting documentation if needed, and request payment by a specific date.
Payment plan: A debtor who acknowledges the debt but cannot pay immediately may be a candidate for a written payment arrangement. The agreement should identify the outstanding balance, installment amounts, payment dates, and consequences of missed payments. Any agreement should also address whether the creditor is accepting less than the full balance.
Legal action: Accounts involving substantial balances, repeated broken promises, prolonged nonpayment, or debtors who have stopped responding may warrant attorney involvement. A formal demand letter may resolve the matter without litigation. If it does not, the business can evaluate whether filing suit is appropriate.
The appropriate response should reflect the circumstances of the account, not simply the number of days it has been overdue.
Consider the Likely Cost of Collection
Before pursuing litigation, you should evaluate whether the potential recovery justifies the expense.
Relevant considerations include attorney fees, court costs, the amount in dispute, the strength of the supporting evidence, and the likelihood that the debtor has assets available to satisfy a judgment.
In Ohio, small claims courts generally have jurisdiction over qualifying money claims of $6,000 or less, excluding interest and costs, under Ohio Revised Code Section 1925.02.
Larger or more complicated claims may require proceedings in municipal or common pleas court. In Ohio, a business should generally budget approximately $150 to $400 for initial court filing and service costs, depending on the court and the number of defendants. Attorney fees for a relatively straightforward collection lawsuit may range from $1,500 to $5,000, while disputed claims requiring discovery, depositions, or trial can cost substantially more. You should also consider the additional expense of collecting a judgment if the debtor does not voluntarily pay. Before filing suit, evaluate the amount owed, the strength of its documentation, the debtor 's ability to pay, and whether the likely recovery justifies the cost of litigation.
You should review whether your agreements permit recovery of attorney fees, collection expenses, or interest. Those amounts are not automatically recoverable merely because an invoice remains unpaid.
Even a favorable judgment does not guarantee payment. The debtor's financial condition and the practical ability to collect should influence the decision.
Three Practical Steps Before 2027
1. Review and prioritize outstanding accounts. Update the aging report, identify disputed balances, and determine which customers need follow-up, payment arrangements, or legal review.
2. Improve collection documentation. Organize contracts, invoices, payment records, and proof of performance. Document payment commitments and resolve billing discrepancies promptly.
3. Strengthen payment practices for 2027. Review written payment terms, deposit requirements, invoicing procedures, and overdue-account follow-up practices. Establish a consistent process for addressing unpaid invoices before balances become difficult to collect.
Unpaid invoices affect cash flow, but pursuing every balance through litigation is rarely the most effective approach. A documented, consistent collection process can help businesses recover outstanding amounts while managing expenses and preserving valuable customer relationships.
Eques Law can assist Ohio businesses, organizations, and individuals with reviewing unpaid accounts, evaluating collection options, preparing demand letters, negotiating payment arrangements, and pursuing legal remedies when appropriate. Contact Eques Law to discuss your outstanding receivables and determine a practical approach to collection.




Comments